1 post tagged “gun control”

One of the strengths of the American system is that it allows itself to make mistakes and then correct them [1]. Today, we were witness to one of them, in Breyer's dissent where  he said:

"In my view, there simply is no untouchable constitutional right guaranteed by the Second Amendment to keep loaded handguns in the house in crime-ridden urban areas."

Let me get this straight - folks in a neighborhood where the police fear to tread in a city known for its high murder rate have no right to keep loaded handguns [2, 3]? IMHO, that is the best reason to uphold a broad interpretation of the second amendment. Had he said "There is no untouchable constitutional right to keep loaded handguns in gated suburban communities with low crime rates", it would have seemed almost reasonable. But to say that folks who live in a crime-ridden area have no Constitutional right to use guns to defend themselves is just silly.

John

[1] Dredd Scott, anyone?
[2] The DC law was a wondreful mass of contradictions. You had to apply for permission to have a handgun, which had to be stored unloaded, trigger-locked [a], and disassembled - but they wouldn't punish you if you used an unlicensed gun to defend yourself. What kind of sense does that make?
[3] Of course, you could strain at gnats and say that the modifier he used ("untouchable") means that there could be some rationale under which you would want those folks not to have guns. But I'll be damned if I know what it is.
[a] The trigger lock makes sense, IMHO - too damn many parents are sloppy about where they store their gun. Hey, Dad - if i can find your stash of Playboys, I can certainly find your 45!